Minutes are quite convenient when we are worried about our teenager's phone. We can see how long they have been on it, decide that it is too long, and have something definite to complain about. An hour has gone by, homework is waiting, and surely there has been enough talking for one afternoon. At least with minutes we know what we are counting.
Then it gets a little less simple. Suppose that hour is a class friendship carrying on after school, with the conversation continuing from where it stopped on the way home. Now suppose the same hour belongs to a lonely teenager looking for company among people they know only online. The clock gives us exactly the same information, while we would probably want to understand rather different things about what is happening.
We may know that our child has been on the phone all afternoon and still know very little about who they are reaching for. And if we start by announcing how much time they have wasted, we have already decided something about a conversation we haven't heard.
Who they are reaching for
A Swedish study gives us a reason to pause here. Researchers used two cross-sectional survey waves, from 2017/18 and 2021/22, involving 3,034 fifteen-year-olds. Intense online communication with close friends and larger groups was associated with better mental well-being. Moderate or intense communication with online-only friends was linked with poorer well-being, especially among girls and teenagers who perceived their families as less affluent.
These surveys cannot tell us what caused what, or which came first. A teenager who feels lonely may look online for company, so we cannot assume that the friendship made them unhappy. Nor can we conclude that knowing someone in person makes a friendship good for them. Most of us know enough about friendships to realise that simply being in the same classroom is no guarantee of kindness.
Privacy, concern and family life
Back at home, though, the minutes are still passing, and someone still needs to put the phone down for dinner. Understanding that a friendship matters doesn't make the rest of family life disappear. It does make it harder to treat every conversation as an unnecessary interruption, especially when friendships are becoming such a large part of our teenager's life and we are no longer included in everything that happens.
That can be uncomfortable. They want more of their life to belong to them, while we are still responsible for a child who may need help and may be quite determined not to ask for it. Wanting to know who they are talking to can come from genuine concern, and still feel like interference to the person being asked. There isn't an easy arrangement in which we get all the reassurance we want and they get all the privacy they want.
Dismissing online friends as people who don't really count probably makes that harder. If those are the people our teenager turns to, the friendship already counts to them. We can take it seriously without assuming that everything about it is fine, just as we can recognise a friend's name from school without assuming there is nothing to worry about.
It may take time to hear about a falling-out at school, or to understand why someone they have never met has become important. Meanwhile, it is much easier to keep returning to the number on the screen. There is a limit we can set, and sometimes we need to set it. When your teenager goes online after school, are they continuing the friendships they already have, or looking for company they are missing elsewhere?
Sources
Keep reading
The School Phone Ban Stops at the Bedroom Door
School phone bans end at the final bell. At home, bedroom phones can keep adolescents connected, alert and awake long after bedtime.
Read more →Why Do We Need Relational Intelligence Now?
Why staying in touch is easy but repairing relationships remains hard, and how relational intelligence grows through ordinary practice.
Read more →When Family Words Mean Different Things
Marriage joins two definitions of closeness, help, loyalty and privacy. Research shows how family tension can become strain between spouses.
Read more →← All Posts